When the Buffalo Bills brought in Amari Cooper this season, it felt like they’d hit the jackpot. A proven playmaker, a four-time Pro Bowler, and a guy who could go toe-to-toe with the league’s best corners-this was supposed to be a game-changer for Buffalo’s Super Bowl aspirations.
Fast forward to the playoffs, and things haven’t exactly gone as planned. Cooper’s numbers have been shockingly low: just two catches for eight yards in two postseason games. Against the Baltimore Ravens in the divisional round? A big, fat zero in the reception column. Not exactly what you’d expect from someone of Cooper’s pedigree.
Now, with the Bills on the cusp of a Super Bowl berth, questions are swirling. Is Cooper being underutilized? Is this a game plan issue? Or is it the dreaded “shrinkage” label that’s followed him since his days in Dallas? Offensive coordinator Joe Brady has a different take.
“Amari’s doing a great job at embracing his role in this offense,”Brady told reporters this week.“Sometimes it’s not about the stats. It’s about what he does just being on the field-drawing coverage, opening things up for the other guys. He knows that.”
Related:
- Super Bowl 2025: date, time, halftime show and everything you need to know
- Where to watch the 2025 Super Bowl? TV channel and streaming where you can watch the game
- Super Bowl 2025 Halftime Show: Everything you need to know about Kendrick Lamar’s show
- Super Bowl Winners List: All the teams that have won the Super Bowl by year
- Gatorade Color Super Bowl: Odds, history and more about the traditional Gatorade bath
To be fair, Brady’s explanation makes sense. Buffalo’s offense thrives on versatility and unpredictability. Stefon Diggs is the clear number one, and guys like Gabe Davis and tight end Dalton Kincaid have made big plays when it counts. But at some point, you’ve got to wonder: why trade for a star receiver if you’re not going to use him as a star?
Amari Cooper’s redemption or repeat? The Bills’ AFC Championship hopes hang in the balance
This isn’t new territory for Cooper. The Cowboys famously offloaded him to Cleveland two years ago, citing his inconsistency in big moments. And now, with the Bills facing a powerhouse Kansas City Chiefs team in the AFC Championship, Cooper’s role-or lack thereof-could be the deciding factor.
Josh Allen will need all the help he can get to outduel Patrick Mahomes. The Chiefs’ secondary isn’t invincible, and Cooper’s route-running ability should, in theory, give Allen a reliable target. But if the Bills keep treating him like a supporting character, it’s hard to see them getting past the Chiefs.
ESPN’s Dan Orlovsky put it bluntly: “If Amari Cooper doesn’t show up, the Bills might as well start packing for the offseason. You can’t have a guy like him out there and not use him when everything’s on the line.“
Sunday’s matchup at Arrowhead isn’t just another game. It’s a test for the Bills, a franchise desperate to break through decades of playoff heartbreak. For Cooper, it’s a chance to rewrite his story and shed the stigma of inconsistency.
The spotlight is on. Now it’s up to Cooper to remind everyone why the Bills went after him in the first place. Will he deliver, or will Buffalo’s season end with more questions than answers? We’ll find out soon enough.